Home » Editor's Picks

Isolation of Toronto Paintball 18 suspects ‘Inhumane…appalling’, say lawyers

Submitted by Editor on April 8, 2007 – 3:37 pmNo Comment

By Colin Perkel

Four Canadian terrorism suspects have been held in extreme isolation for almost a year even though the courts have never ordered their segregation and their trials are months, if not years, away, lawyers close to the case say.

The four are among 18 men and boys in southern Ontario arrested in a blaze of national and international publicity last summer. All were charged with various terrorism-related offences.

In most of the cases, prosecutors asked for and were granted an order that forbids the co-accused from communicating with one another.

That order prompted authorities at the Maplehurst detention centre in Milton, Ont., to lock up a dozen suspects, who did not get bail, in small isolation cells for more than 23 hours a day.

Those conditions are now subject to a legal challenge on the basis they amount to cruel and unusual punishment. In four cases, the non-communication order was never requested, several lawyers told The Canadian Press.

“It’s appalling,” said lawyer Edward Sapiano.

“It’s the non-communication order that is responsible for their isolated segregation.”

Sapiano, who represents Yasim Mohamed, 25, who is accused of importing weapons to benefit a terrorist organization, called the conditions of detention “inhumane.”

The other three accused held in isolation despite the lack of a non-communication order – a situation confirmed in a recent letter to counsel by government lawyer Steve Coroza – are Jamal James, 23, Saad Khalid, 20, and Ali Dirie, 23.

Sapiano said the Crown simply “forgot” to seek the order against the four accused, but it was not immediately clear whether it was in fact an oversight or deliberate.

Some of the lawyers involved were not even aware of the lack of the non-communication order.

Reached by telephone, Coroza said he was discussing the issue with senior Crown counsel and would talk later but then did not return the call.

Conditions of detention for all the accused – most of whom have no criminal record – have become the focus of a legal challenge in Ontario Superior Court on May 7.

The challenge is based in part on the Charter of Rights.

Defence lawyer David Kolinsky, whose client Zakaria Amara, 21, was denied bail, called the segregation cruel and a violation of religious freedoms because the inmates cannot pray together.

CLICK HERE TO READ THE COMPLETE ARTICLE….

Short URL: http://tinyurl.com/yh6zx9y

Comments are closed.